Monday, February 1, 2010

Update February 1, 2010: It Has Been Six Weeks Since A.T. Filed His Report

Six weeks since A.T. tested the failed Bosch dishwasher and determined that the dishwasher failed because of a valve and pump failure which then overwhelmed the patented anti-flooding feature. Six weeks since he filed his report with J.H. of HDI Gerling (Bosch's insurance company).

And almost six months since I first contacted Bosch customer service about the failure of their dishwasher and the flooding of my house. Six months of filing claims, making phone calls, setting up appointments for Bosch technicians to come test the dishwasher, six months of following up, and still no resolution to my claim.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Update: On Dec. 21, 2009, A.T. (Southeast Regional Field Service Manager for Bosch Home Appliances Corp.) Tested the Failed Bosch Dishwasher

After many follow-up calls to J.H. of HDI-Gerling America Insurance Company in Chicago, we finally heard from and scheduled an appointment with A.T. of Bosch Home Appliances Corporation. A.T. is the Southeast Regional Field Service Manager for Bosch Home Appliances in Huntington Beach, California.

He arrived at our home on December 21, 2009. We had scheduled a test of the failed dishwasher with him on our patio.This arrangement was the only way we could have both the water and the electricity required to power the many tests involved in determining the cause of the dishwasher failure we had experienced. This unique testing arrangement actually worked out very well.

After plugging in the electrical outlet on our patio, A.T. hooked up a water line from our exterior water spigot to the dishwasher. Everything worked, so testing could begin.

The tests were thorough and professionally done. He conducted a number of tests, and explained some of them to us. At all times, A.T. was courteous, professional and knowledgeable.

He questioned my husband closely about what the dishwasher looked like when my husband first discovered it was flooding. My husband said, as he has from the beginning, that when he first saw it, the dishwasher was spewing water from all sides, but especially from the upper right corner. Evidently the pressure of the water had breached the seals around the door and allowed the water to come out.

First A.T. tested the drain carrying water from the dishwasher. This was on the right side of the dishwasher. There was no crystalization from water deposits in the pan, meaning that no water had been present in that area. Otherwise the evaporation would have left crystals from the water.

Next he tested the left side of the dishwasher and the intake pump and valve, as well as the anti-flooding feature.

After a while, he told us that, based on what he had observed, the failure was "on our side," and that "Bosch owned it." We were not at fault and we were not responsible for the flooding of May 27, 2009. No operator error.

Apparently, the pump failed and overwhelmed the anti-flooding feature. You can see from the photos that even during the tests, the water began flowing out of the dishwasher onto the concrete of the patio. And the testing did not take very long, compared to running a full load of dishes or compared to the amount of water that could come out during the night. Res ipsa loquitur.

A.T. also said that after the insurance company had settled with us, Bosch would ship the dishwasher to one of its facilities for examination and further testing. This is a good idea, because I don't want anyone to go through what we have gone through.

He said the would file his report to J.H. at Gerling that afternoon, and to let him know if I had not heard from her within a week. That was six weeks ago, and I have not heard a word from anyone at Bosch or Gerling.

On January 8, 2010, as he requested, I called A.T. because I had not heard from J.H. two weeks after the testing. He told me to be patient because these things take time, and we're almost there, and the insurance people have to look at all the laws for my state to see what their liability is. If I didn't know better, I would suspect stalling, delays, and excuses. The old runaround. Videbimus.


Below are some of the photos I took of the testing process and the final results:




























Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Monday, October 26, 2009

How It Happened: The Bosch Dishwasher Flood of Our Home


At 6:30 am on May 27, 2009, my husband went downstairs as usual to make our morning coffee. Unfortunately, we were not able to enjoy our coffee that morning.

In the kitchen, he stepped into 1-1 ½ inches of water covering 2/3 of the kitchen area. It was coming from our Bosch dishwasher, and apparently had been flooding most of the night. Water was still coming out.


This was not a leak of the 2-3 gallons of water used to run a load of dishes. This was a catastrophic failure. My husband turned off the water to the dishwasher, but it continued to drain out for several more hours.

The water had gone under the vinyl flooring, as well as on top, causing the floor to undulate as we walked on it. The water had gone through the floor to the basement below and had flooded the basement as well. The water was raining down through the floor at many points, and had flooded ½ of the basement area. Many of our possessions in that area were soaked. The wood framing and floor joists in the affected area of the basement, from top to bottom, were soaked. The concrete basement floor had water standing on it, increasing as more water came from above.

To say that we were shocked, angered and devastated by what we encountered is an understatement, especially since we were simultaneously dealing with flooding on two floors of our house, caused by a dishwasher with a patented anti-flooding feature.

We had to work fast to stop the flooding and minimize its damage.

On the kitchen level, we started mopping, soaking up water with towels, cutting and removing the vinyl flooring to get to the plywood subfloor, hauling the vinyl flooring outside, wet-vac-ing the water up, opening windows, turning on fans, turning on dehumidifiers, turning on air conditioning, anything to remove the water.

We started moving the contents of the lower kitchen cabinets and the island cabinets to another room. We moved the refrigerator away from the wall to remove the flooring beneath it. In doing so, we noticed that the wall between the refrigerator and the adjacent dining room was also wet. While checking the dining room floor, we saw that the carpet, padding and subfloor in that room were wet as well.

In the basement, we did basically the same thing, mopping the water up, wet-vac-ing the water, and sweeping the water out into the garage and down the driveway. We put out buckets and plastic containers to catch as much dripping water from the ceiling as we could. We moved our possessions in that area out into the driveway, and started trying to dry them off. We set up dehumidifiers and heavy duty fans.

We used fans and dehumidifiers for three weeks before the wood was dry enough for the carpenters to begin their work.

We had to remove all particle board that had gotten wet, because once damp it cannot be salvaged. The toe boards/baseboard in the kitchen had a façade of oak over particle board, so we removed all affected toe boards at the base of the cabinets and the kitchen island, using a moisture meter to determine which wood was wet and which was dry.

By hand, we removed two layers of vinyl flooring down to the plywood subfloor, and began drying out the floor. In the dining room, we tried to dry out the padding, carpet and fiberboard, but gave up on them. In the basement, we used heavy-duty fans and dehumidifiers to dry the wood after sweeping, mopping and wet-vac-ing the water. We carried our wet and damaged personal possessions to dry areas as quickly as we could.

In the coming days and weeks, we contacted our insurance agency, we contacted the carpenter, we shopped for new flooring, we shopped for a new dishwasher. We moved the island and our dining room table and chairs to the den. We packed up the contents of the kitchen island cabinets and our dining room hunt-board, and moved them to other rooms. It was difficult to find things we needed because everything was scattered. We washed dishes by hand for eight weeks while the ongoing repairs were completed.

The repairs had to be orchestrated carefully, with every step done in the correct sequence. For example, the carpenter wanted the dishwasher out so he could accurately measure the cavity for the replacement wood. The flooring people wanted the toe boards/baseboard replaced, but not the molding/trim, before they started on the floor. The appliance people wanted the floor installed before the dishwasher went in. And on and on.

The disruption to our day-to-day lives was substantial, frustrating and time-consuming.


Labels for this post: bosch dishwasher, dishwasher, flood, leaking, water, kitchen, dining room, basement, bosch, flooring, vinyl flooring, particle board, rot, damage, subfloor, plywood, fiberboard, carpet

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

About the Photographs: The Bosch Dishwasher Flood of Our Home

Below are a few of the many photos we took of the Bosch dishwasher flood of our home.

Please bear in mind that these photos were taken several hours after the initial response to the flooding. Because we were so busy dealing with the crisis, it was not until hours later, when we had gained a small degree of control over the situation, that I had time to begin documenting the extent of the damage.

Before we began taking photos, we had to stop the flooding, remove the water, remove two layers of vinyl flooring in the kitchen, and start the fans and dehumidifiers.

These are just a representative sample of the images, designed to provide the viewers with a glimpse of what can happen when a dishwasher floods your home in the middle of the night.


Labels for this post: bosch dishwasher, dishwasher, flood, leaking, water, kitchen, dining room, basement, bosch, flooring, vinyl flooring, particle board, rot, damage, subfloor, plywood, fiberboard, carpet

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, October 22, 2009

The Kitchen: Photos of the Bosch Dishwasher Flood of Our Home















































Labels for this post: bosch dishwasher, dishwasher, flood, leaking, water, kitchen, dining room, basement, bosch, flooring, vinyl flooring, particle board, rot, damage, subfloor, plywood, fiberboard, carpet

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

The Basement: Photos of the Bosch Dishwasher Flood of Our Home

























Labels for this post: bosch dishwasher, dishwasher, flood, leaking, water, kitchen, dining room, basement, bosch, flooring, vinyl flooring, particle board, rot, damage, subfloor, plywood, fiberboard, carpet

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,